The Chicago Wine Company

• Erna Schein Fat Boy Napa Valley 2004

  Red · California · 96 pts

  $50.00
  Go to store
• Etude Oakville Cabernet Sauvignon 2012

  Red · California · 96 pts

  $70.00
  Go to store
• Corliss Estates Syrah 2019

  Red · Washington · 96 pts

  $84.95
  Go to store
• Goodfellow Family Cellars Heritage No. 19 Whistling Ridge Pinot Noir 2021

  Red · Oregon · 96 pts

  $84.95
  Go to store
• Grgich Hills Estate Selection Cabernet Sauvignon Yountville 2005

  Red · Napa Valley · 96 pts

  $150.00
  Go to store
• Markus Molitor Graacher Domprobst Riesling Auslese 2* White Capsule 2019

  White · Mosel · 95 pts

  $49.95
  Go to store
• Cartograph Pinot Noir Floodgate Russian River Valley 2022

  Red · California · 95 pts

  $49.95
  Go to store
• Guido Porro Lazzarito Vigna Santa Caterina 2021

  Red · Piedmont · 95 pts

  $59.95
  Go to store
• Chateau Sixtine Chateauneuf-du-Pape Vatican Reserve 2001

  Red · Rhone Valley · 95 pts

  $65.00
  Go to store
• Castellare di Castellina Trenta Vendemmie 2007

  Red · Tuscany · 95 pts

  $75.00
  Go to store
• Goodfellow Family Cellars Heritage No. 18 Temperance Hill Pinot Noir 2021

  Red · Oregon · 95 pts

  $79.95
  Go to store
• Beau Marchais Clos Pepe Vineyard Ouest Pinot Noir 2020

  Red · California · 95 pts

  $79.95
  Go to store
• Cliff Lede Beautiful Generation Stags Leap District 2012

  Red · California · 95 pts

  $100.00
  Go to store
• Clos du Val Three Graces 2015

  Red · California · 95 pts

  $125.00
  Go to store
• Hewitt Double Plus Cabernet Sauvignon 2018

  Red · California · 95 pts

  $250.00
  Go to store
• Carlisle Bedrock Zinfandel Sonoma Valley 2014

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $35.00
  Go to store
• Bedrock Griffin's Lair Syrah Sonoma Coast 2012

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $40.00
  Go to store
• Agharta Black Label Syrah North Coast 2010

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $45.00
  Go to store
• M. Chapoutier Coteaux d'Aix en Provence Terra d'Or 1998

  Red · Provence · 94 pts

  $50.00
  Go to store
• Copia Cabernet Sauvignon Happy Canyon of Santa Barbara 2020

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $54.95
  Go to store
• San Lorenzo Brunello di Montalcino Bramante 2015

  Red · Tuscany · 94 pts

  $60.00
  Go to store
• Allbaer Grenache La Haut Caelesta Vineyard Paso Robles 2021

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $60.00
  Go to store
• Pierre Paillard Les Parcelles Bouzy Grand Cru XVII Extra Brut NV

  Sparkling · Champagne · 94 pts

  $69.95
  Go to store
• Pehu-Simonet Fins Lieux No. 6 Verzenay Millesime 2014

  Sparkling · Champagne · 94 pts

  $94.95
  Go to store
• Skipstone Alexander Valley Malbec 2021

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $95.00
  Go to store
• Weinlaubenhof Kracher Nouvelle Vague Zweigelt TBA Nr3 2015 (375ml)

  Dessert · Burgenland · 94 pts

  $49.95
  Go to store
• Cayuse Widowmaker Chamberlin Cabernet Sauvignon 2009

  Red · Washington · 94 pts

  $110.00
  Go to store
• Aubert Chardonnay Sonoma Coast Reuling 2009

  White · California · 94 pts

  $110.00
  Go to store
• Beta Vare Vineyard Oak Knoll District Cabernet Sauvignon 2019

  Red · California · 94 pts

  $110.00
  Go to store
• A.P. Vin Clos Pepe Vineyard Pinot Noir 2014

  Red · California · 93 pts

  $35.00
  Go to store
• Vincent Armstrong Vineyard Pinot Noir Ribbon Ridge 2019

  Red · Oregon · 93 pts

  $39.95
  Go to store
• Orin Swift Trigger Finger California 2017

  Red · California · 93 pts

  $44.95
  Go to store
• Weinlaubenhof Kracher Zwischen den Seen Welschriesling TBA Nr. 2 2015 (375ml)

  Dessert · Burgenland · 93 pts

  $49.95
  Go to store
• Ovid Experiment K 2005

  Red · California · 93 pts

  $110.00
  Go to store
• Checkerboard Diamond Mountain District Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 (1.5L)

  Red · California · 93 pts

  $405.00
  Go to store
• Vindemio Imagine 2010

  Red · Rhone · 92 pts

  $35.00
  Go to store
• Ron Noble Chardonnay Steiner Vineyard Sonoma Mountain 2018

  White · California · 92 pts

  $40.00
  Go to store
• Loring Rosellas Pinot Noir Santa Lucia Highlands 2011

  Red · California · 92 pts

  $44.95
  Go to store
• Allbaer La Haut Sangiovese Paso Robles 2021

  Red · California · 92 pts

  $60.00
  Go to store
• Nickel & Nickel Martin Stelling Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2006

  Red · California · 92 pts

  $90.00
  Go to store
• Bernard Magrez Paciencia 2005

  Red · Toro · 92 pts

  $100.00
  Go to store
• TOR Beckstoffer To Kalon Old B Cabernet Sauvignon 2009

  Red · California · 92 pts

  $150.00
  Go to store
• Kongsgaard Fimasaurus 2011

  Red · California · 92 pts

  $175.00
  Go to store
• Two Hands Sophie's Garden Shiraz Padthaway 2003

  Red · South Australia · 91 pts

  $55.00
  Go to store
• Lucia Bortolussi Saint-Emilion Grand Cru 2006

  Red · Bordeaux · 90 pts

  $23.97
  Go to store
• Château d'Arsac The Winemakers' Collection Cuvée N°3 Andrea Franchetti 2007

  Red · Bordeaux · 90 pts

  $29.95
  Go to store
• Maculan Madoro 2006

  Red · Veneto · 90 pts

  $34.97
  Go to store
• Williams Selyem Allen Russian River Valley Pinot Noir 2013

  Red · California · 90 pts

  $95.00
  Go to store

Per bottle, before shipping and tax. Typical price is the median other stores charge for the same vintage and bottle size. A deal is 20% or more below typical.